The Peer Review Process of Alhadharah: Jurnal Ilmu Dakwah (AJID)

Alhadharah: Jurnal Ilmu Dakwah (AJID) employs a rigorous peer review process to ensure the quality and validity of its published research. The double-blind process maintains anonymity for both authors and reviewers. Experts in the relevant fields evaluate submissions based on their scientific significance, innovation, and alignment with the journal's aims.

1. Preliminary Assessment: The editorial team initially screens each manuscript to confirm its alignment with the journal’s focus and publication standards. Manuscripts that do not meet these criteria or show more than 20% similarity to existing works are immediately rejected. The team also checks for adherence to formatting and citation guidelines. Non-compliant manuscripts are returned for correction and resubmission. Manuscripts that pass this initial screening proceed to the peer review stage.

2. Selection of Reviewers: The editorial board selects at least two independent reviewers who are experts in the manuscript’s subject area. Both reviewers and authors remain anonymous to each other. The board ensures that reviewers are from different institutions than the authors and carefully considers their expertise and potential conflicts of interest before inviting them to review. The goal is to appoint reviewers within four weeks.

3. Evaluation Process: Reviewers evaluate the manuscript’s scientific rigor, originality, validity, and relevance to the field, typically within two weeks. They provide detailed feedback for authors, recommending acceptance, revisions, or rejection.

4. Editorial Decision: The editor-in-chief makes the final decision to accept, reject, or request revisions based on the reviewers’ feedback and compliance with publication standards. If there is a significant divergence in reviewer opinions, an additional reviewer may be consulted. The decision and anonymous reviewer comments are communicated to the authors. The target is to issue the first decision within a month and to publish accepted manuscripts within 4 to 8 weeks of acceptance.

5. Revision Stage: Authors of manuscripts requiring revisions must address the reviewers’ suggestions and resubmit the revised version, clearly highlighting the changes and including a response letter. The deadline for minor revisions is two weeks, while major revisions are due within four weeks. Manuscripts undergoing major revisions are re-evaluated by the original reviewers to confirm the adequacy of the changes.

6. Final Steps to Publication: Accepted manuscripts undergo copyediting and formatting before publication.

Through this meticulous peer review process, Alhadharah: Jurnal Ilmu Dakwah (AJID) ensures the publication of research that upholds the highest standards of scholarly integrity and quality.